Who Killed Sherlock Holmes?

There are some questions that practically demand an answer, and then there are questions like Who Killed Sherlock Holmes? which have the added advantage of being utterly ridiculous until you stop and think about them. What do you do when the world’s most famous fictional detective turns out to have a ghost, and somebody murders it? If you’re Detective Inspector James Quill and his increasingly battered team of Shadow Police, you presumably add it to the list of things you never expected to encounter when you joined the Met. Paul Cornell’s third novel in the series takes this gloriously bonkers premise and turns it into another thoroughly dark, frequently unsettling investigation into London’s supernatural underworld.

The idea that Sherlock Holmes exists as a ghost, sustained by the memories and imaginations of the people who have read about him, is a wonderful starting point. His murder is more than an amusing literary conceit, though. It sets Quill and his colleagues on the trail of a criminal genius who appears to be recreating the circumstances of famous Holmes stories, with real people suffering the consequences. Suddenly, recognising a reference to Arthur Conan Doyle isn’t merely a matter of showing off one’s literary knowledge. It might be the difference between working out what’s happening and arriving too late to prevent another death. Cornell has clearly had fun with the Holmes mythology, but he also understands how to make the familiar strange again.

Of course, the team has rather more to worry about than a literary murder mystery. The Shadow Police have been through Hell, quite literally, and their ability to perceive London’s hidden supernatural reality has done little to make their lives easier. If anything, the strain is beginning to tear them apart. What makes this such an effective continuation is that the investigation and the characters’ personal problems are closely connected. They’re not a well-oiled unit of supernatural specialists who can put their private concerns aside whenever a monster appears. They’re damaged people attempting to do a difficult job while struggling with problems that don’t politely wait for the end of a case.

Quill is still trying to maintain control, but the pressure is taking a serious toll on his sanity. He’s a policeman who wants evidence, explanations and something resembling order, yet his experiences have repeatedly shown him that the world is far more complicated than his professional instincts can accommodate. I found his struggle particularly compelling because his determination to keep going is both admirable and worrying. He’s the sort of man who feels responsible for the people around him, which makes it difficult for him to admit when he’s no longer coping. The trouble is that leadership becomes a rather dangerous business when your own judgement is under strain.

Costain has a different battle to fight, one that goes beyond the immediate danger posed by the investigation. His struggle with his soul gives the supernatural elements a deeply personal dimension. For him, the existence of Hell isn’t an abstract theological question or another bizarre fact about London. It’s a very real prospect that forces him to confront the life he’s led and the person he’s become. I’ve always found flawed characters more interesting when their shortcomings have consequences, and Costain’s predicament gives his attempts to do the right thing genuine urgency. He can’t simply decide to be a better man and assume that the past will conveniently stop mattering.

Sefton, meanwhile, is increasingly concerned with holding the team together. His loyalty is one of his more appealing qualities, but it also makes him vulnerable to taking risks when he sees his colleagues falling apart. There’s something quietly moving about the fact that, amid all the supernatural horrors and increasingly elaborate mysteries, he still wants to preserve the human relationships that make the work bearable. His determination to help the others is not without its dangers, particularly when keeping everyone together seems to require him to push himself beyond sensible limits. I found his role a useful reminder that a team can be threatened just as effectively by the damage its members carry as by whatever is waiting for them outside.

Lisa Ross’s story takes her in another direction, as her attraction to an actor who may be something considerably more than he appears becomes part of her search for happiness. Her personal journey adds an interesting complication to a novel already crowded with mysteries. Ross isn’t simply trying to solve the case or support her colleagues. She’s also looking for something that might make her own life feel less painful, and that leaves her open to possibilities she might otherwise approach with greater caution. I liked the way Cornell allows that desire to influence her decisions without making her seem foolish for wanting something beyond the grim business of policing London’s supernatural horrors.

There are moments when the competing character arcs and the increasingly intricate Holmes-inspired mystery threaten to overwhelm one another. Cornell has a lot going on, and readers who aren’t already invested in the team may find the story a little unforgiving. For me, though, the personal struggles are precisely what stop the novel becoming an elaborate puzzle in which the characters exist merely to connect clues. The mystery is clever, but the emotional consequences are what give it weight.

The book also continues the series’ bleak vision of London as a place where the supernatural reflects and magnifies the darkness already present in ordinary life. The Sight offers no reassuring division between the respectable city and the horrors beneath it. It reveals a world in which power, fear and human weakness are every bit as important as magic, and where understanding what’s happening doesn’t guarantee that you can stop it. Cornell’s combination of police procedural, urban fantasy and horror remains distinctive, even when the plot occasionally becomes a little overcomplicated.

Damian Lynch’s narration is once again a strong fit. He gives the police dialogue a natural, grounded quality while distinguishing the characters through their delivery and expression. The more emotionally demanding scenes benefit from his restraint, and he handles the darker supernatural passages without making them unnecessarily theatrical. His performance helps preserve the balance between the absurdity of the central premise and the very real distress experienced by the people caught up in it.

There’s a particularly frustrating note to the ending when you know that this is, for now, the last Shadow Police novel. Publishing difficulties meant that the planned continuation never materialised, leaving Cornell’s wider story unfinished. That’s a real shame, because this is a series with plenty of life left in it, and the characters have earned the chance to see their journeys through. Cornell has indicated that enough interest could potentially make a return viable, so if you’ve enjoyed these books, making your enthusiasm known might genuinely help.

Who Killed Sherlock Holmes? is an imaginative, darkly entertaining addition to the series, with a wonderfully odd central mystery and a cast whose personal struggles give the supernatural proceedings real emotional weight. It’s occasionally crowded, but I enjoyed the way the Holmes mythology becomes something genuinely sinister rather than just a collection of clever references. More than anything, I’m disappointed that we don’t get to follow Quill and his team further. If enough readers ask for more, perhaps the Shadow Police might yet return. I’d certainly be among those asking.

Buy your copy here

link to Waylander's Wandering Ko-Fi page for tips and subscriptions

Waylander's Wandering
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.