“This is an OUTRAGE! – Crawler #4119 (GC, BWR, NW Princess Donut the Queen Anne Chonk)”

By this point in the Dungeon Crawler Carl series, I have completely stopped trying to predict what Matt Dinniman is going to throw at Carl and Princess Donut next. This Inevitable Ruin proves once again that the series can take an already ridiculous premise, expand it to an absurd scale and somehow make the whole thing work. The dungeon has become a sprawling intergalactic conflict, the stakes are higher than ever and the characters are facing situations that would have seemed completely impossible back at the beginning of the series. Yet beneath all the chaos, Dinniman continues to deliver the same combination of humour, action and surprisingly powerful emotional storytelling that has made these books so addictive.

The most obvious change this time around is the scale of the conflict. Faction Wars has arrived, and it turns out to be part Command & Conquer, part Warhammer, and all cheating. That is probably the simplest way of describing an increasingly complicated battlefield where strategy, resources, alliances and outright manipulation all matter. The game within the game becomes a spectacular extension of everything that has come before, taking the dungeon’s competitive nature and turning it into something considerably more dangerous.

What makes it particularly entertaining is the sheer amount of chaos involved. There is strategy, there is military planning, there are increasingly ridiculous weapons and there are factions attempting to outmanoeuvre one another. Then there is the cheating. Lots and lots of cheating. Nobody seems particularly interested in playing fair when the consequences of losing are so enormous, and that creates exactly the sort of gloriously unpredictable situations that this series thrives upon.

The action is essentially non-stop. Dinniman throws one crisis after another at Carl and his allies, giving the story an almost relentless momentum. Battles escalate, plans go wrong and seemingly impossible situations become even more impossible. Yet despite the constant action, the book never becomes emotionally hollow. In fact, some of the deepest emotional beats in the series appear here. The characters have now been through so much that their relationships carry genuine weight, and the consequences of their choices can be genuinely painful.

That is perhaps the most impressive thing about This Inevitable Ruin. Dinniman has somehow managed to make a series built around dungeon crawling, absurd monsters and reality television satire into a story about friendship, loyalty, sacrifice and survival. Carl’s determination to destroy the crawl remains the driving force behind much of the narrative, but his reasons have become increasingly personal. The people around him are no longer simply fellow survivors. They are his friends, his family and the people he has chosen to protect.

Princess Donut remains one of the great joys of the series. Her personality is as enormous as ever, and her ability to turn even the most serious situation into something gloriously absurd has not diminished. At the same time, her development over the course of the series has made her far more than comic relief. The relationship between Donut and Carl continues to provide the emotional foundation that allows the story to move between ridiculous comedy and genuine tragedy without either side feeling out of place.

The supporting cast has also become increasingly important. After so many books, these are characters whose successes and failures genuinely matter to the reader. Dinniman understands that emotional investment makes the action more effective. When the fighting begins, we care about who survives. When someone is placed in danger, it matters. When a character makes a sacrifice, the consequences are felt.

Jeff Hays once again deserves enormous credit for making all of this work in audiobook form. His narration has become an essential part of the identity of Dungeon Crawler Carl. He brings an enormous cast to life with an astonishing range of voices and personalities, making every character instantly recognisable. His comic timing remains exceptional, but it is his handling of the emotional material that really stands out. He knows when to make a scene hilarious and when to let the emotion sit without overplaying it.

Hays also makes the increasingly ridiculous world feel real. That is no small achievement when the story can move from intense military engagements to utterly absurd conversations within minutes. He commits completely to every character and every situation, which allows the listener to accept even the strangest developments as part of this universe.

This Inevitable Ruin is another hugely entertaining instalment in a series that continues to exceed expectations. The action is relentless, the Faction Wars are gloriously chaotic, the humour remains sharp and the emotional beats hit harder than ever. The overarching story continues its massive escalation, while Carl’s determination to bring the crawl crashing down feels more urgent with every book.

It is difficult to know where Dinniman can possibly take the story next, but after this much insanity I have learned not to underestimate him. Whatever comes next, I suspect it will be bigger, stranger, funnier and probably considerably more traumatic than anything I am currently expecting. And, frankly, I cannot wait.

Buy your copy here